Ashland Ohio State Trooper Violated 4th Amendment in 45-Minute ‘Fishing Expedition’: Extreme Targeting Campaign

0

ASHLAND, OHIO – On November 3, 2025, State Trooper Kevin Peshak initiated a traffic stop as part of an ongoing enforcement operation within city limits. Positioned outside a local daycare, Peshak observed a driver depart with his daughter; as the man pulled out, he reached for his phone after it slid off the passenger seat, providing the grounds for the stop.  The driver immediately pulled into a nearby shopping plaza at 3:25 PM and remained fully compliant, rolling down his window promptly, providing his license, registration and insurance. Despite the driver’s clarification that he was not actively texting or calling, Trooper Peshak issued a citation for a first-offense distracted driving violation – which was within his right to do.  However, what wasn’t within his right was the unconstitutional overreach and participating in the extreme targeting of the individual…

As the clock ticked toward his children’s bus arrival of 4:05 PM, what began as a routine traffic stop for a simple citation devolved into an unlawful “fishing expedition.” Despite witnessing the man depart the daycare with his daughter, Trooper Peshak—as part of a pattern of extreme targeting—detained the victim for 45 minutes to investigate nonexistent protection order violations against his daughter. With no reasonable, articulable suspicion of a separate crime, this prolonged detainment violated his Fourth Amendment rights. The unnecessary delay ultimately forced the man to frantically arrange emergency childcare when he was prevented from meeting his children at their stop.

The story of my life, constantly pulled over,” – VICTIM

video
play-rounded-fill

“The story of my life, constantly pulled over,” the man says as the video begins, timestamping his recording. The officer had already initiated the stop, collecting license and insurance documentation and stating the violation. Although the interaction started at 3:25 PM, with the video starting at 3:30 PM, the driver wasn’t cleared to leave until 4:10 PM, making for a unbelievable 45-minute ordeal.  The traffic stop was unlawful and a prolonged detention that far exceeded the time “reasonably required” to address the initial violation (which was something as simple as writing a ticket and checking license and registration) – therefore clearly violating his 4th Amendment Rights.

WHAT THE LAW SAYS

Stops exceeding 20-30 minutes without additional justification for a K-9 unit are often considered unreasonable. In Ohio, an unreasonable traffic stop extension regarding a protection order occurs when law enforcement continues to detain a driver after the original purpose of the stop (e.g., speeding, broken taillight, distracted driver) is completed, without having reasonable, articulable suspicion that a violation of a protection order is actually occurring.   

Under Ohio and Federal Law, a stop becomes an “unreasonable seizure” if, after the officer has finished the tasks related to the traffic violation, they continue to detain the individual without new, independent suspicion. 

  • No “Fishing Expeditions”: If an officer stops a car for a minor violation, completes that investigation, and has no evidence that a protection order is being violated, any further detention to run background checks for protection orders is unreasonable.
  • Post-Traffic Stop Detention: If a driver is told they are getting a warning or a first time citation, but is then held for another 10–30 minutes without cause to check for protection orders, this is an illegal extension.
Key Factors in Ohio Courts
  1. Scope of Investigation: The investigation must be limited to the original reason for the stop unless new suspicion arises.
  2. Objective Standard: The officer must be able to point to specific facts that created the suspicion of a violation, not just a hunch or a “gut feeling”.
  3. Duration: A routine traffic stop generally should not last much longer than necessary to handle the citation, with excessive wait times for records checks often deemed unreasonable. 

NOT AN ISOLATED INCIDENT

Trooper Kevin Peshek violated a man’s 4th Amendment Rights as part of an extreme targeting operation.
This isn’t an isolated incident pertaining to the Ashland State Troopers. Just days prior, on October 30, 2025, the same individual was intercepted by Trooper Guinther of the Ashland State Highway Patrol. Though the Cadillac XT5’s lighting system was fully functional moments earlier, the stop was initiated for a headlight warning with the driver stating that the somewhat newly acquired vehicle had been having headlight issues as of recent but that all running lights, fog lights and other lights seemed to be working.
Having recently survived a traumatic encounter (just a few weeks prior) where he was held at gunpoint, unlawfully detained and arrested during a previous stop by Ashland City Police, the driver was understandably anxious. In an effort to prioritize transparency and his safety, he rolled down all windows and unbuckled his seatbelt to retrieve his wallet from the back pocket before the Trooper approached. When the trooper questioned the lack of a seatbelt, the driver—disoriented by the stress of the situation—remarked that he felt cursed when picking up food in the city. Despite the context and the initial warning for the headlight, the trooper issued a citation for the seatbelt violation.
READERS NOTE:  The individual in question in this article has been victimized by the City of Ashland, the Ashland Municipal Courts, the Ashland Common Pleas Courts, the Ashland Police Department and many other individuals in their respective duties inside and outside of the local jurisdictional body in more than a dozen instances since 2024.  The victim initially took both charges to trial, but after being threatened and intimidated by Judge John L. Good just days prior, he opted to simply pay the tickets on the day of trial – just moments beforehand.

If you or anyone you know has anything to share in regards to the developing situation taking place in Ashland Ohio please feel free to utilize any of our contact methods located below.  Your communication is safe, secure, confidential and anonymous.

Tip-Line: (703) 747-9270

Email: Contact Us

Online Form: Submit a Tip

THE BOTTOM LINE

SCUMBAGGED Tip:  The city of Ashland is a very small city where everyone knows everyone and law enforcement communicate with one another regarding situations and individuals to the highest degree of perhaps any other city in the United States.  These might appear to be routine stops, but they aren’t – they are a form of harassment, intimidation and extreme targeting that have been fully documented and are being actively investigated.

AËTOS SAYS:  This is clearly just more unconstitutional behavior from Ashland and it’s co-conspirators.  In Ashland they believe they are ABOVE the law as opposed to upholding the law and they think they can get away with it – because they always have had no accountability, until now…

 

Post your comment below! Choose to remain anonymous or feel free to use any name of your choosing (your identity and personal information will always be protected).

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here